Assessing the catch efficiency of predators in the presence of prey using experimental gillnets in a temperate estuary
Document Type
Article
Publication Date
9-1-2022
Abstract
Fishery-independent sampling is designed to representatively sample faunal communities based on the effort-standardized catch rates of individual gears. In estuaries, experimental gillnets are widely used due to their ability to passively sample mobile fish communities with multiple panels of decreasing mesh sizes. To test if concurrently collected prey in experimental gillnets create a trophic-related sampling bias for predatory or scavenging (hereafter, predators) species, we set large mesh gillnets comprising two treatments, baited (n = 80) and unbaited (n = 78), using a paired design in Back Sound, North Carolina. Furthermore, we analyzed data from the North Carolina Division of Marine Fisheries (NC DMF) estuarine gillnet monitoring program with boosted regression tree models to correlate estuarine predator occurrence with environmental factors (salinity, temperature), habitat presence, and families of common prey species as predictor variables. In our experimental manipulation, neither total catch nor community composition statistically varied between treatments, determined using permutational multivariate analysis of variance (PERMANOVA). However, species richness estimated using species accumulation curves was higher in baited gillnets, with one frequently caught species (Atlantic sharpnose sharks) collected exclusively in baited gillnets. In NC DMF surveys, prey group variables were more important (average model importance; 10% ± 8.8% SD) than habitat composition (2% ± 1.7%) to the presence of predators, but less than abiotic environmental variables (21.1% ± 13.1%). This combined manipulative and mensurative study revealed mixed evidence towards increased catch efficiency of predatory fish collected in widely used experimental gillnets. These results should be considered in refining abundance estimations for estuarine predators, as catch efficiency for some piscivorous predators may vary in relation to the abundance and catch efficiency of prey.
Publication Source (Journal or Book title)
Fisheries Research
Recommended Citation
Plumlee, J., Roskar, G., Craig, J., & Fodrie, F. (2022). Assessing the catch efficiency of predators in the presence of prey using experimental gillnets in a temperate estuary. Fisheries Research, 253 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fishres.2022.106383